You have a tube or profile that has to survive heat, harsh chemistry, or repeated sterilization. Three families keep showing up on the shortlist: PEEK, PEI (often specified as Ultem), and the sulfones (PSU, PPSU, PES). They overlap enough to look interchangeable on a datasheet and behave nothing alike on the line. This is a practical guide to choosing between them for high-temperature polymer extrusion, written from the extruder's chair rather than the spec sheet.
Start With the Real Decision
The choice is rarely "which polymer is best." It's "which polymer meets the part's thermal and chemical demands at a cost and processability you can actually run." Over-specify and you pay for PEEK when a sulfone would have done the job. Under-specify and you get a part that crazes in the field or yellows after twenty autoclave cycles. Get the trade-off right up front and the rest of the program goes smoother.
The Three Families at a Glance
PEEK is a semi-crystalline aromatic thermoplastic. It has a glass transition near 145°C and melts around 340°C, so melt processing runs in the 360–400°C range and needs equipment built for it. It brings the best mechanical strength, chemical resistance, and continuous-use temperature of the three. It's also the most expensive and the most demanding to extrude well.
PEI (Ultem) is amorphous, with a Tg around 215–217°C. It processes at high temperature but below PEEK, and because it's amorphous it doesn't crystallize — which changes how it behaves as it cools. PEI gives you high strength, dimensional stability, and broad sterilization compatibility, including repeated steam autoclaving, at a lower cost than PEEK.
Sulfones (PSU, PPSU, PES) are also amorphous, with Tg values roughly from 185°C (PSU) to 220–225°C (PPSU and PES). They process in a similar 350–400°C window. PPSU stands out for sterilization endurance and impact strength; PSU is the value option; PES sits at the high end for heat resistance. As a family they're the practical middle ground between commodity engineering resins and PEEK.
When Each One Wins
By temperature
For the highest continuous-use temperature and mechanical load, PEEK wins. If your service temperature sits below roughly 170–180°C and you mainly need to survive sterilization heat, PEI or a sulfone usually covers it without PEEK's price or processing headaches.
By chemistry
PEEK has the broadest chemical resistance, including aggressive solvents. Amorphous materials — PEI and the sulfones — are more prone to environmental stress cracking against certain solvents and lipids. If the part sees harsh chemistry under stress, weigh that carefully before choosing an amorphous resin.
By sterilization
All three handle steam autoclave at 121–134°C. The differentiator is cycle life and cosmetics. PPSU holds up through many repeated cycles with minimal loss and low yellowing, which is why it's common on reusable instruments. Some PEI grades are formulated to hold ductility and color across hundreds of cycles. If the device is single-use and gamma- or EO-sterilized, the field opens up and cost moves to the front.
By cost
Rough order, low to high: PSU, then PPSU/PES and PEI in the middle, then PEEK at the top. The gap is large. For many reusable applications, a sulfone delivers what the program needs at a fraction of PEEK's material cost.
By processability and crystallization
PEI and the sulfones are amorphous, so cooling is more forgiving — no crystallization to manage, more predictable dimensions. PEEK is semi-crystalline and crystallizes slowly, which gives a usable processing window but makes cooling and annealing decisive. Get PEEK's thermal profile wrong and you get inconsistent crystallinity, and with it inconsistent stiffness, clarity, and dimensional stability down the length of the extrudate.
Common Pitfalls
- Choosing on Tg or melt point alone. Datasheet numbers don't tell you how a resin behaves through the die and quench.
- Under-drying. All three are hygroscopic. Skip proper drying and you'll chase bubbles, splay, and molecular-weight loss.
- Ignoring crystallization on PEEK. Treating PEEK cooling like an amorphous resin is the fastest way to a part that drifts out of spec after it relaxes. More in Semi-Crystalline PEEK Tubing: Why Crystallinity Decides How Your Part Performs.
- Solvent surprises with amorphous grades. A part that passes on the bench can stress-crack in service if the solvent-under-stress case wasn't checked.
- Sterilization method assumed, not confirmed. The right choice for repeated steam autoclave is often wrong for a single-use gamma part.
Talk It Through Before You Cut Tooling
Material selection and line setup are tied together, and the cheapest place to fix a bad match is before the die is built. If you're weighing PEEK extrusion against PEI or a sulfone for a specific tube, profile, or catheter component, we're happy to look at your part, your sterilization path, and your line and think it through with you.
Have a part, a material question, or a line to scope? Book a 30-minute call with Jonathan or send a note.